Sacra Latina

Douay-Rheims & Vulgata Clementina

Sacra Latina
← Prev Next →
Douay-Rheims
Vulgata

1 Objection 1: It seems that there is not will in God. For the object of will is the end and the good. But we cannot assign to God any end. Therefore there is not will in God.

1 Ad primum sic proceditur. Videtur quod in Deo non sit voluntas. Obiectum enim voluntatis est finis et bonum. Sed Dei non est assignare aliquem finem. Ergo voluntas non est in Deo.

2 Objection 2: Further, will is a kind of appetite. But appetite, as it is directed to things not possessed, implies imperfection, which cannot be imputed to God. Therefore there is not will in God.

2 Praeterea, voluntas est appetitus quidam. Appetitus autem, cum sit rei non habitae, imperfectionem designat, quae Deo non competit. Ergo voluntas non est in Deo.

3 Objection 3: Further, according to the Philosopher De Anima iii, 54), the will moves, and is moved. But God is the first cause of movement, and Himself is unmoved, as proved in Phys. viii, 49. Therefore there is not will in God.

3 Praeterea, secundum philosophum, in III de anima, voluntas est movens motum. Sed Deus est primum movens immobile. Ut probatur VIII Physic. Ergo in Deo non est voluntas.

4 On the contrary, The Apostle says Rm. 12, 2): That you may prove what is the will of God.

4 Sed contra est quod dicit apostolus, Rom. XII, ut probetis quae sit voluntas Dei.

5 I answer that, There is will in God, as there is intellect: since will follows upon intellect. For as natural things have actual existence by their form, so the intellect is actually intelligent by its intelligible form. Now everything has this aptitude towards its natural form, that when it has it not, it tends towards it; and when it has it, it is at rest therein. It is the same with every natural perfection, which is a natural good. This aptitude to good in things without knowledge is called natural appetite. Whence also intellectual natures have a like aptitude as apprehended through its intelligible form; so as to rest therein when possessed, and when not possessed to seek to possess it, both of which pertain to the will. Hence in every intellectual being there is will, just as in every sensible being there is animal appetite. And so there must be will in God, since there is intellect in Him. And as His intellect is His own existence, so is His will.

5 Respondeo dicendum in Deo voluntatem esse, sicut et in eo est intellectus, voluntas enim intellectum consequitur. Sicut enim res naturalis habet esse in actu per suam formam, ita intellectus intelligens actu per suam formam intelligibilem. Quaelibet autem res ad suam formam naturalem hanc habet habitudinem, ut quando non habet ipsam, tendat in eam; et quando habet ipsam, quiescat in ea. Et idem est de qualibet perfectione naturali, quod est bonum naturae. Et haec habitudo ad bonum, in rebus carentibus cognitione, vocatur appetitus naturalis. Unde et natura intellectualis ad bonum apprehensum per formam intelligibilem, similem habitudinem habet, ut scilicet, cum habet ipsum, quiescat in illo; cum vero non habet, quaerat ipsum. Et utrumque pertinet ad voluntatem. Unde in quolibet habente intellectum, est voluntas; sicut in quolibet habente sensum, est appetitus animalis. Et sic oportet in Deo esse voluntatem, cum sit in eo intellectus. Et sicut suum intelligere est suum esse, ita suum velle.

6 Reply to Objection 1: Although nothing apart from God is His end, yet He Himself is the end with respect to all things made by Him. And this by His essence, for by His essence He is good, as shown above Question 6, Article 3): for the end has the aspect of good.

6 Ad primum ergo dicendum quod, licet nihil aliud a Deo sit finis Dei, tamen ipsemet est finis respectu omnium quae ab eo fiunt. Et hoc per suam essentiam, cum per suam essentiam sit bonus, ut supra ostensum est, finis enim habet rationem boni.

7 Reply to Objection 2: Will in us belongs to the appetitive part, which, although named from appetite, has not for its only act the seeking what it does not possess; but also the loving and the delighting in what it does possess. In this respect will is said to be in God, as having always good which is its object, since, as already said, it is not distinct from His essence.

7 Ad secundum dicendum quod voluntas in nobis pertinet ad appetitivam partem, quae licet ab appetendo nominetur, non tamen hunc solum habet actum, ut appetat quae non habet; sed etiam ut amet quod habet, et delectetur in illo. Et quantum ad hoc voluntas in Deo ponitur; quae semper habet bonum quod est eius obiectum, cum sit indifferens ab eo secundum essentiam, ut dictum est.

8 Reply to Objection 3: A will of which the principal object is a good outside itself, must be moved by another; but the object of the divine will is His goodness, which is His essence. Hence, since the will of God is His essence, it is not moved by another than itself, but by itself alone, in the same sense as understanding and willing are said to be movement. This is what Plato meant when he said that the first mover moves itself.

8 Ad tertium dicendum quod voluntas cuius obiectum principale est bonum quod est extra voluntatem, oportet quod sit mota ab aliquo. Sed obiectum divinae voluntatis est bonitas sua, quae est eius essentia. Unde, cum voluntas Dei sit eius essentia, non movetur ab alio a se, sed a se tantum, eo modo loquendi quo intelligere et velle dicitur motus. Et secundum hoc Plato dixit quod primum movens movet seipsum.

Word list
I q. 19 a. 1: Whether there is will in God? · 127 unique words
Study these words
Nouns (29)
anima, animae f · 1st
soul
essentia, essentiae f · 1st
essence ×5
forma, formae f · 1st
form, figure ×4
natura, naturae f · 1st
nature ×2
physica, physicae f · 1st
the Physics
apostolus, apostolī m · 2nd
apostle
deus, deī m · 2nd
God, god ×14
modus, modī m · 2nd
manner, mode
philosophus, philosophī m · 2nd
philosopher
romanus, romanī m · 2nd
Roman
obiectum, obiectī n · 2nd
object ×4
finis, fīnis m · 3rd · i-stem
end, boundary ×5
Plato m · 3rd
Plato
bonitas, bonitātis f · 3rd
goodness, integrity
cognitio, cognitiōnis f · 3rd
examination, inquiry, investigation
habitudo, habitudinis f · 3rd
relation, disposition ×3
imperfectio, imperfectionis f · 3rd
imperfection
pars, partis f · 3rd · i-stem
part, region
perfectio, perfectionis f · 3rd
perfection, completion
ratio, ratiōnis f · 3rd
reason, account
voluntas, voluntātis f · 3rd
will, desire ×19
animal, animalis n · 3rd · i-stem
animal, living thing, offspring
actus, actūs m · 4th
act, deed ×3
appetitus, appetitūs m · 4th
appetite, desire ×4
intellectus, intellectūs m · 4th
comprehension, understanding ×5
motus, motūs m · 4th
movement, motion
respectus, respectūs m · 4th
a looking back, regard
sensus, sensūs m · 4th
feeling, sense
res, reī f · 5th
res ×4
Verbs (30)
amō, amāre, amāvī, amātum 1st conj
love, like
assignō, assignāre, assignāvī, assignātum 1st conj
assign, distribute
delectō, delectāre, delectāvī, delectātum 1st conj
delight, please
designō, designāre, designāvī, designātum 1st conj
to mark out, designate
nominō, nomināre, nomināvī, nominātum 1st conj
name, call
probō, probāre, probāvī, probātum 1st conj
approve, esteem, commend, recommend, certify ×2
vocō, vocāre, vocāvī, vocātum 1st conj
call, summon
careo 2nd conj
lack, be without
habeō, habēre, habuī, habitum 2nd conj
have, hold ×15
moveō, movēre, movī, motum 2nd conj
move, stir ×7
oportet, oportēre, oportuit 2nd conj
it is necessary, it behooves ×2
pertineō, pertinēre, pertinuī, pertentum 2nd conj
reach ×2
respondeō, respondēre, respondī, responsum 2nd conj
answer
videō, vidēre, vīdī, vīsum 2nd conj
see
appeto 3rd conj
seek, desire ×2
apprehendō, apprehendere, apprehendī, apprehensum 3rd conj
seize, lay hold of
competo 3rd conj
be suitable, befit
consequor, consequī, consecūtus sum 3rd conj
obtain, attain
dīcō, dīcere, dīxī, dictum 3rd conj
say, speak ×8
intelligō, intelligere, intellēxī, intellēctum 3rd conj
understand ×3
loquor, loquī, locūtus sum 3rd conj
speak
ostendō, ostendere, ostendī, ostentum 3rd conj
show
ponō, ponere, posuī, positum 3rd conj
put, place, set
procedō, procedere, processī, processum 3rd conj
proceed
quaerō, quaerere, quaesīvī, quaesītum 3rd conj
seek
quiescō, quiescere, quiēvī, quietum 3rd conj
rest, keep quiet, calm ×2
tendō, tendere, tetendī, tentum 3rd conj
stretch, spread, extend
fīō, fierī, factus sum irreg
happen, come about
sum, esse, fuī, futūrus irreg
be ×36
volō, velle, voluī irreg
wish, will, want ×2
Adjectives (16)
bonus, -a, -um 1st
good ×8
suus, -a, -um 1st
his/her/their own ×9
tertius, -a, -um 1st
third
alius, alia, aliud (gen. usually alterīus) 2nd
other, another ×2
appetitivus, -a, -um 1st/2nd
appetitive, desiring
divinus, -a, -um 2nd
divine, of a deity, god
primus, -a, -um 2nd
first, foremost, best ×4
secundus, -a, -um 2nd
next, following
immobilis, -e 3rd
immovable
indifferens 3rd
not differing, indifferent
intellectualis, -e 3rd
intellectual
intelligibilis, -e 3rd
intelligible ×2
naturalis, -e 3rd
natural, normal ×4
omnis, -e 3rd
all, every
principalis, -e 3rd
chief, principal
similis, -e 3rd
like, similar
Pronouns (15)
is, ea, id
he, she, it; this, that ×10
nōs, nostrī / nostrum
we
quī, quae, quod
who, which ×13
uterque, utraque, utrumque
each of two, both
hic, haec, hoc
this, this one; (adv.) here ×6
īdem, eadem, idem
the same
ille, illa, illud
that; he, she, it ×2
ipse, ipsa, ipsum
himself, herself, itself; very ×5
sēipse, sēipsa, sēipsum
himself, herself, itself (emphatic)
suī, sibi, sē
of himself, herself, itself ×2
aliquī, aliqua, aliquod
anyone, anybody, anything
aliquis, aliqua, aliquid
anyone, anybody, anything
quīdam, quaedam, quoddam
a certain one, someone
quīlibet, quaelibet, quodlibet
any (you please), whatever ×4
nihil (indēcl.)
nothing
Indeclinables & other (37)
a + abl
from, by ×3
ab + abl
from, by ×5
ad + acc
to, toward ×10
contra + acc
against, facing
de + abl
from, concerning ×2
extra + acc
outside of, beyond
in + abl
in, into, on ×19
per + acc
through ×5
secundum + acc
according to ×3
supra + acc
above, beyond
ita adv
thus, so ×2
non adv
not ×12
praeterea adv
besides, furthermore ×2
quando adv
when, at what time ×2
quantum adv
how much, as far as
scilicet adv
namely, that is to say
semper adv
always
sic adv
so, thus ×2
solum adv
only, just, merely, barely, alone
tantum adv
so much, so far
unde adv
from where, whence ×3
autem conj
but, however ×2
cum conj
when, since ×7
enim conj
namely ×4
ergo conj
therefore ×4
et conj
and ×14
etiam conj
and also, besides, furthermore
licet conj
although, granted that ×2
quod conj
because, as far as ×7
sed conj
but ×6
sicut conj
as, just as ×4
tamen conj
yet, nevertheless ×2
ut conj
that, so that; as ×8
vero conj
yes
duodecim num
twelve
octo num
eight
trēs, tria num
three