Sacra Latina

Douay-Rheims & Vulgata Clementina

Sacra Latina
← Prev Next →
Douay-Rheims
Vulgata

1 Objection 1: It seems that God does not will things apart from Himself. For the divine will is the divine existence. But God is not other than Himself. Therefore He does not will things other than Himself.

1 Ad secundum sic proceditur. Videtur quod Deus non velit alia a se. Velle enim divinum est eius esse. Sed Deus non est aliud a se. Ergo non vult aliud a se.

2 Objection 2: Further, the willed moves the willer, as the appetible the appetite, as stated in De Anima iii, 54. If, therefore, God wills anything apart from Himself, His will must be moved by another; which is impossible.

2 Praeterea, volitum movet voluntatem, sicut appetibile appetitum, ut dicitur in III de anima. Si igitur Deus velit aliquid aliud a se, movebitur eius voluntas ab aliquo alio, quod est impossibile.

3 Objection 3: Further, if what is willed suffices the willer, he seeks nothing beyond it. But His own goodness suffices God, and completely satisfies His will. Therefore God does not will anything apart from Himself.

3 Praeterea, cuicumque voluntati sufficit aliquod volitum, nihil quaerit extra illud. Sed Deo sufficit sua bonitas, et voluntas eius ex ea satiatur. Ergo Deus non vult aliquid aliud a se.

4 Objection 4: Further, acts of will are multiplied in proportion to the number of their objects. If, therefore, God wills Himself and things apart from Himself, it follows that the act of His will is manifold, and consequently His existence, which is His will. But this is impossible. Therefore God does not will things apart from Himself.

4 Praeterea, actus voluntatis multiplicatur secundum volita. Si igitur Deus velit se et alia a se, sequitur quod actus voluntatis eius sit multiplex, et per consequens eius esse, quod est eius velle. Hoc autem est impossibile. Non ergo vult alia a se.

5 On the contrary, The Apostle says 1 Thess. 4, 3): This is the will of God, your sanctification.

5 Sed contra est quod apostolus dicit, I Thess. IV, haec est voluntas Dei, sanctificatio vestra.

6 I answer that, God wills not only Himself, but other things apart from Himself. This is clear from the comparison which we made above Article 1). For natural things have a natural inclination not only towards their own proper good, to acquire it if not possessed, and, if possessed, to rest therein; but also to spread abroad their own good amongst others, so far as possible. Hence we see that every agent, in so far as it is perfect and in act, produces its like. It pertains, therefore, to the nature of the will to communicate as far as possible to others the good possessed; and especially does this pertain to the divine will, from which all perfection is derived in some kind of likeness. Hence, if natural things, in so far as they are perfect, communicate their good to others, much more does it appertain to the divine will to communicate by likeness its own good to others as much as possible. Thus, then, He wills both Himself to be, and other things to be; but Himself as the end, and other things as ordained to that end; inasmuch as it befits the divine goodness that other things should be partakers therein.

6 Respondeo dicendum quod Deus non solum se vult, sed etiam alia a se. Quod apparet a simili prius introducto. Res enim naturalis non solum habet naturalem inclinationem respectu proprii boni, ut acquirat ipsum cum non habet, vel ut quiescat in illo cum habet; sed etiam ut proprium bonum in alia diffundat, secundum quod possibile est. Unde videmus quod omne agens, inquantum est actu et perfectum, facit sibi simile. Unde et hoc pertinet ad rationem voluntatis, ut bonum quod quis habet, aliis communicet, secundum quod possibile est. Et hoc praecipue pertinet ad voluntatem divinam, a qua, per quandam similitudinem, derivatur omnis perfectio. Unde, si res naturales, inquantum perfectae sunt, suum bonum aliis communicant, multo magis pertinet ad voluntatem divinam, ut bonum suum aliis per similitudinem communicet, secundum quod possibile est. Sic igitur vult et se esse, et alia. Sed se ut finem, alia vero ut ad finem, inquantum condecet divinam bonitatem etiam alia ipsam participare.

7 Reply to Objection 1: The divine will is God's own existence essentially, yet they differ in aspect, according to the different ways of understanding them and expressing them, as is clear from what has already been said Question 13, Article 4). For when we say that God exists, no relation to any other object is implied, as we do imply when we say that God wills. Therefore, although He is not anything apart from Himself, yet He does will things apart from Himself.

7 Ad primum ergo dicendum quod, licet divinum velle sit eius esse secundum rem, tamen differt ratione, secundum diversum modum intelligendi et significandi, ut ex superioribus patet. In hoc enim quod dico Deum esse, non importatur habitudo ad aliquid, sicut in hoc quod dico Deum velle. Et ideo, licet non sit aliquid aliud a se, vult tamen aliquid aliud a se.

8 Reply to Objection 2: In things willed for the sake of the end, the whole reason for our being moved is the end, and this it is that moves the will, as most clearly appears in things willed only for the sake of the end. He who wills to take a bitter draught, in doing so wills nothing else than health; and this alone moves his will. It is different with one who takes a draught that is pleasant, which anyone may will to do, not only for the sake of health, but also for its own sake. Hence, although God wills things apart from Himself only for the sake of the end, which is His own goodness, it does not follow that anything else moves His will, except His goodness. So, as He understands things apart from Himself by understanding His own essence, so He wills things apart from Himself by willing His own goodness.

8 Ad secundum dicendum quod in his quae volumus propter finem, tota ratio movendi est finis, et hoc est quod movet voluntatem. Et hoc maxime apparet in his quae volumus tantum propter finem. Qui enim vult sumere potionem amaram, nihil in ea vult nisi sanitatem, et hoc solum est quod movet eius voluntatem. Secus autem est in eo qui sumit potionem dulcem, quam non solum propter sanitatem, sed etiam propter se aliquis velle potest. Unde, cum Deus alia a se non velit nisi propter finem qui est sua bonitas, ut dictum est, non sequitur quod aliquid aliud moveat voluntatem eius nisi bonitas sua. Et sic, sicut alia a se intelligit intelligendo essentiam suam, ita alia a se vult, volendo bonitatem suam.

9 Reply to Objection 3: From the fact that His own goodness suffices the divine will, it does not follow that it wills nothing apart from itself, but rather that it wills nothing except by reason of its goodness. Thus, too, the divine intellect, though its perfection consists in its very knowledge of the divine essence, yet in that essence knows other things.

9 Ad tertium dicendum quod ex hoc quod voluntati divinae sufficit sua bonitas, non sequitur quod nihil aliud velit, sed quod nihil aliud vult nisi ratione suae bonitatis. Sicut etiam intellectus divinus, licet sit perfectus ex hoc ipso quod essentiam divinam cognoscit, tamen in ea cognoscit alia.

10 Reply to Objection 4: As the divine intellect is one, as seeing the many only in the one, in the same way the divine will is one and simple, as willing the many only through the one, that is, through its own goodness.

10 Ad quartum dicendum quod, sicut intelligere divinum est unum, quia multa non videt nisi in uno; ita velle divinum est unum et simplex, quia multa non vult nisi per unum, quod est bonitas sua.

Word list
I q. 19 a. 2: Whether God wills things apart from Himself? · 140 unique words
Study these words
Nouns (22)
anima, animae f · 1st
soul
essentia, essentiae f · 1st
essence ×2
apostolus, apostolī m · 2nd
apostle
deus, deī m · 2nd
God, god ×11
modus, modī m · 2nd
manner, mode
finis, fīnis m · 3rd · i-stem
end, boundary ×6
thessalonicensis, thessalonicēnsis m · 3rd · i-stem
of Thessalonica, Thessalonian
bonitas, bonitātis f · 3rd
goodness, integrity ×8
habitudo, habitudinis f · 3rd
relation, disposition
inclinatio, inclinationis f · 3rd
inclination
perfectio, perfectionis f · 3rd
perfection, completion
potio, potionis f · 3rd
a drink, a draught ×2
ratio, ratiōnis f · 3rd
reason, account ×4
sanctificatio, sanctificatiōnis f · 3rd
holiness
sanitas, sanitātis f · 3rd
sanity, reason ×2
similitudo, similitūdinis f · 3rd
likeness, imitation ×2
voluntas, voluntātis f · 3rd
will, desire ×14
actus, actūs m · 4th
act, deed ×3
appetitus, appetitūs m · 4th
appetite, desire
intellectus, intellectūs m · 4th
comprehension, understanding
respectus, respectūs m · 4th
a looking back, regard
res, reī f · 5th
res ×3
Verbs (35)
communicō, communicāre, communicāvī, communicātum 1st conj
share ×3
derivo 1st conj
draw off, derive
importo 1st conj
imply, bring in
multiplicō, multiplicāre, multiplicāvī, multiplicātum 1st conj
multiply
participō, participāre, participāvī, participātum 1st conj
share
satiō, satiāre, satiāvī, satiātum 1st conj
satisfy, fill
significō, significāre, significāvī, significātum 1st conj
signify, indicate
appareō, apparēre, apparuī, apparitum 2nd conj
appear ×2
condeceo 2nd conj
to be fitting, to befit
habeō, habēre, habuī, habitum 2nd conj
have, hold ×4
moveō, movēre, movī, motum 2nd conj
move, stir ×6
pateō, patēre, patuī 2nd conj
be open, lie open
pertineō, pertinēre, pertinuī, pertentum 2nd conj
reach ×3
respondeō, respondēre, respondī, responsum 2nd conj
answer
videō, vidēre, vīdī, vīsum 2nd conj
see ×3
acquirō, acquirere, acquisīvī, acquisitum 3rd conj
acquire, obtain
agō, agere, ēgī, āctum 3rd conj
do, drive, deal
cognosco 3rd conj
become acquainted with ×2
consequor, consequī, consecūtus sum 3rd conj
obtain, attain
dīcō, dīcere, dīxī, dictum 3rd conj
say, speak ×10
diffundō, diffundere, diffundī, diffusum 3rd conj
diffuse
faciō, facere, fēcī, factum 3rd conj
do, make
intelligō, intelligere, intellēxī, intellēctum 3rd conj
understand ×4
introducō, introducere, introduxī, introductum 3rd conj
introduce, bring
perficiō, perficere, perfecī, perfectum 3rd conj
complete, finish
procedō, procedere, processī, processum 3rd conj
proceed
quaerō, quaerere, quaesīvī, quaesītum 3rd conj
seek
quiescō, quiescere, quiēvī, quietum 3rd conj
rest, keep quiet, calm
sequor 3rd conj
follow ×3
sufficiō, sufficere, suffecī, suffectum 3rd conj
be sufficient, suffice ×3
sumō, sumere, sumpsī, sumptum 3rd conj
take up ×2
differō, differre, distulī, dīlātum irreg
postpone, delay, differ
possum, posse, potuī irreg
be able, can
sum, esse, fuī, futūrus irreg
be ×30
volō, velle, voluī irreg
wish, will, want ×28
Adjectives (25)
amarus, -a, -um 1st
bitter, brackish
bonus, -a, -um 1st
good ×5
diversus, -a, -um 1st
different, diverse
perfectus, -a, -um 1st
perfect, complete ×2
proprius, -a, -um 1st
own, very own ×2
suus, -a, -um 1st
his/her/their own ×10
tertius, -a, -um 1st
third
tōtus, -a, -um (gen. tōtīus) 1st
whole, all
alius, alia, aliud (gen. usually alterīus) 2nd
other, another ×25
divinus, -a, -um 2nd
divine, of a deity, god ×10
multus, -a, -um 2nd
much, many ×3
primus, -a, -um 2nd
first, foremost, best
secundus, -a, -um 2nd
next, following ×2
ūnus, -a, -um (gen. ūnīus) 2nd
one ×5
vester, vestra, vestrum 2nd
your (pl.)
appetibilis, -e 3rd
desirable
dulcis, -e 3rd
pleasant, charming
impossibilis, -e 3rd
impossible ×2
multiplex, gen. multiplicis 3rd
having many twists, turns
naturalis, -e 3rd
natural, normal ×3
omnis, -e 3rd
all, every ×2
possibilis, -e 3rd
possible ×3
similis, -e 3rd
like, similar ×2
simplex, gen. simplicis 3rd
single
superior, gen. superiōris 3rd
above, high
Pronouns (12)
is, ea, id
he, she, it; this, that ×13
quī, quae, quod
who, which ×17
quīcumque, quaecumque, quodcumque
whoever, whatever
hic, haec, hoc
this, this one; (adv.) here ×13
ille, illa, illud
that; he, she, it ×2
ipse, ipsa, ipsum
himself, herself, itself; very ×3
suī, sibi, sē
of himself, herself, itself ×19
aliquī, aliqua, aliquod
anyone, anybody, anything ×2
aliquis, aliqua, aliquid
anyone, anybody, anything ×7
quīdam, quaedam, quoddam
a certain one, someone
quis, quid
who? what?
nihil (indēcl.)
nothing ×4
Indeclinables & other (46)
a + abl
from, by ×15
ab + abl
from, by
ad + acc
to, toward ×10
contra + acc
against, facing
de + abl
from, concerning
ex + abl
out of, from ×4
extra + acc
outside of, beyond
in + abl
in, into, on ×11
per + acc
through ×4
propter + acc
because of ×5
secundum + acc
according to ×6
secus + acc
beside, near
ideo adv
therefore
inquantum adv
in so far as ×3
ita adv
thus, so ×2
magis adv
to greater extent, more nearly
maxime adv
especially, chiefly
non adv
not ×16
praecipue adv
especially
praeterea adv
besides, furthermore ×3
prius adv
earlier, before
sic adv
so, thus ×3
solum adv
only, just, merely, barely, alone ×4
tantum adv
so much, so far
unde adv
from where, whence ×4
autem conj
but, however ×2
cum conj
when, since ×3
enim conj
namely ×4
ergo conj
therefore ×4
et conj
and ×15
etiam conj
and also, besides, furthermore ×5
igitur conj
therefore, so, then ×3
licet conj
although, granted that ×3
nisi conj
if not ×6
quia conj
because, for ×2
quod conj
because, as far as ×16
sed conj
but ×8
si conj
if, if only ×3
sicut conj
as, just as ×5
tamen conj
yet, nevertheless ×3
ut conj
that, so that; as ×10
vel conj
or
vero conj
yes
quārtus, -a, -um num
four
quattuor num
four
trēs, tria num
three